The report by Alan Milburn, into young people not earning, not in education, or in training, which I think is bound to be accepted, is going to, quite properly, place on Parliament the enormous legislative and regulation-making burden of fundamentally rewriting the benefits system and creating vastly increased infrastructure for support into employment.
There will not be, nor should there be, any parliamentary time available to any measure that detracts from this objective. It has to be the priority of work, our main effort. I see it as a moral imperative to rescue a generation from a workless life, with all the disadvantages that come with such purposeless existence.
So into this imperative, the Government has hurled its latest distraction from what must become our work for the remainder of the Parliament. It has introduced the daftest of bills: The Conversion Practices Bill. A better name for it would be ‘The prevention of dissuasion Bill’: a bill to prevent anyone from being dissuaded from doing something which they haven’t thought through properly and may come to bitterly regret later.
This bill has its genesis in the prevention of discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation, where homosexual desire was considered disordered, so that treatment ought to be available to correct it. When I was at school in the early nineteen seventies, a boy showing an unnatural interest in other boys would be sent off to see a psychiatrist. There were however, a number of other aversion therapies advocated by cranks, exorcists and a variety of other practitioners.
The motive to address these practices has diminished first, because overwhelmingly homosexual relationships are accepted as feature of normal society, and therefore the desire to ‘correct’ orientation has almost completely disappeared. And second, because all the egregious practices have already been outlawed given that they constitute coercive behaviour and outright assault.
Nevertheless, the Government is determined to press ahead with the unnecessary measure, justifying it by including attempts to reorientate individuals who wish to change their sex.
Anyone who thought that we had seen off the ideological fanatics who believe that we can change our sex, defined by the chromosomes in every cell in our bodies, can think again: the woke brigade are alive and still campaigning: Stonewall is back advising government.
Unlike sexual partners, which can be changed if preference changes (and, apparently, it can do), sex change may involve chemical and physical alterations with profound and irreversible changes, which will prove truly dreadful, if and when, the changed person decides that it was a mistake.
The huge danger of the Bill is that it does not offer protection to parents, clinicians, therapists or clergy who might engage with their child, patient, or congregant, to ensure that they have fully thought through the consequences and are not doing something that they may later bitterly regret. Under the provisions of the Bill, such conversations may constitute an offence as an attempt at ‘conversion’.
Parents have a duty to prevent their children from doing things that may turn out to be profoundly wrong for them. But this goes well beyond parents, it affects us all. Freedom of expression requires are that we are all entitled to have our say, and offer our advice to a friend or acquaintance entertaining such change. Just as they have the right to reject or to refuse that advice.
But to criminalise such advice is a profound threat to liberty.
Of course, the Bill has no provision to address the industry and charities that have grown to encourage and promote sex change
