I watched the Foreign Office Minister of State, Hamish Falconer, performing a ‘clip’ on social media, promoting the Government’s EU reset agreement. He was wandering round a supermarket taking items off the shelves and placing them in his basket, whilst explaining why they are now so much more expensive than before Brexit. To illustrate his point, with each
item from the shelves, he also placed into his basked the wad of bureaucratic paperwork now required to import or export each item. His point being, that if only we’d stayed in the EU, our shopping would be so much less expensive.
It is a good story with which to justify the Government’s ‘reset’ agenda, but it would be irresponsible not to spoil it with the facts. It is indeed true that the price of food shopping in the UK has risen by 25% since the end of 2019. Blaming it on Brexit, however, is absurd because over the same period, food shopping in the EU, has risen by fully 30%: The better-off-in argument defies the facts.
That said, of course the Government is right to try and secure a better Brexit deal, that objective should always be on the agenda of any UK government irrespective of the political party in power.
The current arrangement, whereby food exports require intrusive and expensive border checks accompanied by a mountain paper certification, to be stamped by a wet stamp, in this digital age, is just bonkers.
Ten years ago, when I was the Minister for International Development, I was responsible for a project we funded, which made for seamless electronic borders to ensure frictionless trade between states in darkest Africa. Yet here we are, in modern Europe, stamping bits of paper.
Of course, we should be negotiating to improve it. The reality is however, that this antediluvian system was put in place by the EU as a deliberate strategy to punish us for leaving.
The EU is quite capable of making arrangements with non-EU countries for mutual recognition and acceptance of food standards. It has done so with New Zealand. That it wouldn’t recognise our own standards, notwithstanding having shared those standards with them for 40 years, is a measure of the obduracy and spitefulness of the club of which we had been a member.
So, when we negotiate with them for improvements, we need to bear in mind exactly the proven nature of the beast with which we are negotiating, and therefore, to do so from a position of strength.
Instead, the Government approached the talks, as a supplicant, a beggar even. So eager were ministers for a deal, any deal, that they placed themselves at the mercy of the EU Commission, despite all our long experience of negotiating with that monster.
It need not have been so. We had a trump card. We had in our possession something that the Commission really, really wanted: access to our fisheries. So, instead of negotiating ‘hard ball’ , we conceded, at the very outset, access to our waters for 12 years as a goodwill gesture, without getting anything in return, despite our long experience that there is no goodwill in EU negotiations.
The deal the Government has agreed is deeply irresponsible. It may be to the advantage of those relatively modest food exports to the EU, but it places on every domestic food producer, an unquantifiable regulatory burden: For we have consented to implement foreign regulations, that have yet to be made, and whose costs we cannot possibly know. What a humiliation.
